That does not mean, however, that "the exact amount in figures must be stated in the agreement." On August 13, 2018, a jury agreed with defendants. Built in 2016, this 33,000 square foot gem belongs to Dana Mecum of Mecum Collector Car Auction Fame. at 554. 's Reply Supp. WebMecum Auctions reverses course on expansion Scott Williams Sep 26, 2018 Located in a former Piggly Wiggly grocery store at 445 S. Main St., Mecum Auctions has decided not to expand on adjacent property purchased from the village four years ago. Defendants contend that plaintiff waived this issue by failing to raise it in the pretrial order as an issue for either the Court or the jury to address. Pl. (quotations omitted). Therefore, the Harper court was only deciding whether terms of the "unenforceable" AIA contract could be considered in assessing the architect's reasonable compensation in an action for quantum meruit. Whats this older portly gentleman of considerable worth, and poor architectural taste, doing around Geneva Lake now? WebDana Mecum Archives - Geneva Shore Report Tag: Dana Mecum Stay Up to Date with the NEWS king-of-kings-landscaping Follow Us Home Delivery Autographed The Cowardly Lion, Click on image Autographed Island In The Sand, Click on Image The Bering Sea, an Arch Patton CIA Adventure, click on image Our Favorite Websites WebDana Mecum's house Yerkes Observatory James Athan's house South Shore Club Wayne Kocourek's house Fred B. Jones House (FLW) Charles Ross House by Frank Lloyd Wright George W. Spencer House by Frank Lloyd Wright A. P. Johnson House (FLW) Lee Tenzer's house William McEssy's house Plane Down in a Field Advertisement Around The roof is cedar shake with copper gutters and downspouts. Play Audio | Show Directions. You cant exactly predict what businesses are going to do in five years, he said. Plaintiff argues that the AIA's integration clause prohibits the Court from looking "to extrinsic evidence beyond the AIA document itself to define the price term. But Mecum contested the decision in a motion for judgment, asserting the jury erred by not noticing the AIA-standard contract did not specify the price the architects would receive for their services. But the village, he added, also could use an extra $100,000 in revenue to shore up its budget. (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); Sprawling Shingle Style Car Enthusiasts Lake House by Lowell Custom Homes (PHOTOS A custom lake house with no less than twenty garage bays and a presence on GenevaLake like no other has become the talk of the lake. by Geneva Shore Report | Jun 14, 2017 | Articles, Our Place | 1 |. Shortcuts Go to photos Go to comments Go to map View nearby buildings Reviews about Add comment Plaintiff argues that the jury verdict is fatally flawed because the evidence established the AIA contract was missing an essential termprice. Dana Mecum Auctions; Dana Mecum Health; Dana Mecum Wife; Dana Mecum Wiki; How Old Is Dana Mecum; Dana Mecum Car Collection; Dana Mecum Net Worth; Dana And Patti Mecum; Dana Mecum House Lake Geneva Murder Mystery; Dana Mecum House Lake Geneva; Dana Mecum; real estate It is unknown whether the minaret is representative of DanaMecums religious affiliation or not. And the judge said that was good enough to validate the contract and uphold the jury verdict. WebDana Mecum's house Gregg Kunes' house Plane Down in a Field Pat Ryan's house John Sandner's house Richard Driehaus' House Bill Wrigley, Jr.'s house Advertisement Around the World Mailing List Comments Policies Your Name Comment Please enter the Anti-Spam code Reload Advertisement Nearby: Lee Tenzer's house Wayne Kocourek's house {{start_at_rate}} {{format_dollars}} {{start_price}} {{format_cents}} {{term}}, {{promotional_format_dollars}}{{promotional_price}}{{promotional_format_cents}} {{term}}. On the issue of the real estate transaction, Magers wrote that Mecum Auctions would either make the $100,000 payment to the village or give the property back to the village, apparently forgoing the $25,000 resale price negotiated earlier. Mr. John Halverson will go into the meeting looking one way and then come out looking another. In his ruling, however, Weisman noted the contract required Mecum to pay the architects 14 percent of the total cost of the work. A custom lake house with no less than twenty garage bays and a presence on Geneva Lake like no other has become the talk of the lake. 2017) (stating that "[a] contract [that] does not specify a price . Dana Mecum is the CEO of Mecum Auctions, one of the industrys most well-known collector car auction companies. Defendants said the parties entered into a standard American Institute of Architects ("AIA") written agreement, which contains an arbitration clause. The council meets on Monday night. Plaintiff relies heavily on Harper, Drake & Associates v. Jewett & Sherman Co., 182 N.W.2d 551 (Wis. 1971) to support his position that the price as defined in the AIA contract was not sufficiently definite. The sprawling shingle style residence was custom built to exacting standards by Wisconsin-based homebuilders Lowell Custom Homes in 2016 for a homeowner with a Dana Mecum is an American businessman who has a net worth of $50 million. (quotation omitted); see Herder Hallmark Consultants, Inc. v. Regnier Consulting Grp., Inc., 685 N.W.2d 564, 567 (Wis. Ct. App. Additionally, the Harper court cites approvingly to Barnes v. Lozoff, 123 N.W.2d 543 (1963), noting that "[i]n Barnes, the parties made a contract and specified how the architects would be compensated." In response, the leadership of the city will gather together and listen to the entertainer named Disturbed singing a great hushed rendition of the Sounds of Silence by Simon and Garfunkel. By the way, that architectural shot comes from floating by his new residence on Lake Genevas shoreline. According to Lake Geneva News, Mecum is planning a $26.5 million expansion in Walworth, the centerpiece of which is a permanent auction location. Dana is the president and founder of Mecum Auctions, launching the company from his kitchen table with the help of his wife, Patti, and a few close friends back in 1988. Top Secret. Motion to go into Closed Session pursuant to Wis. Stat. There was no written project description or estimate of cost of the project. The Court "will overturn a jury verdict for a [party] only if [it] conclude[s] that no rational jury could have found for [that party]." 2009) ("Although the remedy of quantum meruit was developed as part of the common law of contracts to avoid unjust enrichment under a contract implied by law, equitable considerations influence the determination of whether recovery is warranted in a given case. You know him, the guy who bought the old Piggly Wiggly by Geneva Shore Report | May 10, 2017 | Articles, Our Place | 0 |. Mr. Mecum, doing a Mutt and Jeff routine with a friend, walked into the store and berated the owner, blaming her for buying the gold coin, and then demanding it back. Geneva Lake audio guide for boats: stories from the water, Cruise around Geneva Lake and retrace the history of its former residents, If you select the default Hide My Email option, please make sure you also use Sign in with Apple when you log into VoiceMap on other devices, We use cookies to make VoiceMap easier to navigate. Whats this older portly gentleman of considerable worth, and poor architectural taste, doing around Geneva Lake now? According to Lake Geneva News, Mecum is planning a $26.5 million expansion in Walworth, the centerpiece of which is a permanent auction location. The architect then sought recovery based on quantum meruit, using a cost-of-construction percentage in seeking compensation. Resp. CHICAGO A federal court in Chicago has upheld a ruling that a dispute between a Lake Geneva, Wis., man and a group of architects over compensation for a home construction project is subject to arbitration, as the judge said the contract's provision granting the architects a percentage cut of the total project price was the same as specifying an exact amount of money due. Moreover, Harper simply cannot be understood to mean that a contract term that is premised on a percentage of value of future activity is not sufficiently definite to form a contract. WebMecum Auctions reverses course on expansion Scott Williams Sep 26, 2018 Located in a former Piggly Wiggly grocery store at 445 S. Main St., Mecum Auctions has decided not to expand on adjacent property purchased from the village four years ago. at 557 (emphasis added). (See Defs.' Rather, "the price must, by the terms of the agreement, be capable of being definitely ascertained." Our Place Dana Mecum; the auto auction guy. WALWORTH After years of expansion ideas and talks, Mecum Auctions is backing away from plans for building on property that the company acquired from the village of Walworth. Also on the property is a boat house, docks and water feature. Located in a former Piggly Wiggly grocery store at 445 S. Main St., Mecum Auctions has decided not to expand on adjacent property purchased from the village four years ago. WebDana Mecum is the CEO of Mecum Auctions, one of the industrys most well-known collector car auction companies. I drive past Mecums construction site every week. Not until he gets out of the bureaucratic rehab the city pays for using workers compensation insurance. Theres more info in our. Yet, Barnes was a cost-of-construction case premised on a verbal contract and a general description of project to build a fifty-six-unit motel. Included in the Lake Geneva-Wisconsin (WI) Category: residential. Its owned by American businessman and owner of Mecum Auctions, Dana Mecum and wife, Patti. Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, United States. What sort of auctioneer-type character is Dana Mecum? Photography by Victoria McHugh Photography. Full title: DANA MECUM, Plaintiff, v. WEILERT CUSTOM HOMES, LLC, LIEDERBACH & GRAHAM. WebRelated searches Dana Mecum House. Matter Law, ECF 213 at 3), apparently without objection from defendants. Dana earned his fortune as the founder of the car auction company, Mecum Auctions. Dana earned his fortune as the founder of the car auction company, Mecum Auctions. By the way, that architectural shot comes from floating by his new residence on Lake Genevas shoreline. In that case, an architecture firm sued to recover for services it had provided to defendant pursuant to an alleged contract. WebBuilt in 2016, this 33,000 square foot gem belongs to Dana Mecum of Mecum Collector Car Auction Fame. The company is still owned by founder and president Dana Mecum, who ran the business with his wife and four sons for decades. The Harper court rejected this approach in assessing an appropriate recovery. WebDana Mecum Archives - Geneva Shore Report Tag: Dana Mecum Stay Up to Date with the NEWS king-of-kings-landscaping Follow Us Home Delivery Autographed The Cowardly Lion, Click on image Autographed Island In The Sand, Click on Image The Bering Sea, an Arch Patton CIA Adventure, click on image Our Favorite Websites Waite v. Bd. Court decision behind the $1.8 million Ford GT auction revealed as www.foxnews.com/auto/court-decision-behind-the-1-8. (Photo by Scott Williams/Regional News) Scott Williams In 1909, it was selected by Ladies Home Journal as one of the 12 most beautiful country homes in America. In deciding a Rule 50 motion, the Court views the evidence "in the light most favorable to the non-moving party." The GSR has threatened to sue the city if it proceeds with the annexation. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Full title:DANA MECUM, Plaintiff, v. WEILERT CUSTOM HOMES, LLC, LIEDERBACH & GRAHAM, Court:UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS EASTERN DIVISION. Altogether in 2017, Mecum will handle some 20,000 consignments, including 14,000 cars, and generate revenues in (quotation omitted). Lake Geneva, Wisconsin (WI), US Dana Mecum is the CEO of Mecum Auctions, one of the industrys most well-known collector car auction companies. Find Awesome Results For Dana Mecum House! What about the fox in the hen house? Lake Geneva Farmers Market is officially open for the 2017 season. Lindquist Ford, Inc. v. Middleton Motors, Inc., 557 F.3d 469, 478 (7th Cir. Mecum asserted the work was done on a handshake deal, but the defendants stated Mecum had signed a standard American Institute of Architects written agreement, which included an arbitration clause. Incidentally, DanaMecums business is in the Town of Walworth (the old Piggly Wiggly building), but dont go over there to look at any of the cars he sells on television. The Court says "apparently" because the transcript of plaintiff's closing argument is not on the docket and was not provided to the Court by either party. Resp. Either way would be a good way to go.. However, that language must be considered dicta because quantum meruit is an equitable remedy, not a contractual remedy. Closed Session. But in an email to the village earlier this month, Magers reported that because of higher-than-expected costs, Mecum will not be pursuing any of its expansion or other development options. That passion ensured that there would be an abundance of garage space. Mecums passion for collector cars meant it had to have plenty of garage space and not just any kind of garage space; he went with a fieldstone, multi-car, show garage with glass garage doors, porcelain flooring and a rooftop swimming pool. Second, plaintiff is seeking to enforce a clause of a contract that he claims does not exist. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. ", He also mentioned that "based on the evidence presented, plaintiff, more than defendants, had the ability to control the size, scope and most importantly, the cost, of the project. Coll. Harper is distinguishable on two fronts. We have received all of the bids for the various building options, Magers wrote Sept. 4. Here, the AIA contract defined how cost of construction would be calculated, (see Pl. A custom lake house with no less than twenty garage bays and a presence on Geneva Lake like no other has become the talk of the lake. DANA MECUM, Plaintiff, v. WEILERT CUSTOM HOMES, LLC, LIEDERBACH & GRAHAM ARCHITECTS, PHILLIP J. LIEDERBACH, and R. MICHAEL GRAHAM, Defendants. There are several problems with this argument. Id. Under the circumstances, the Harper court said, "[i]t would abuse the fundamental precepts of contract interpretation to hold that [defendant] bound himself and his company to pay five percent of whatever [plaintiff] should later decide would be the actual cost of the building." WebBuilt in 2016, this 33,000 square foot gem belongs to Dana Mecum of Mecum Collector Car Auction Fame. UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS EASTERN DIVISION. Dana Mecum is an American businessman who has a net worth of $50 million. Dana Mecum's house Location show on map Lake Geneva-Wisconsin (WI) Category: residential Section: Residential Dana Mecum is the CEO of Mecum Auctions, one of the industrys most well-known collector car auction companies. Links: www.mecum.com 31,254 views 7.6 ( 14 votes) Categories Buildings > Residential Comments Policies Please log in if you don't want to post anonymously (anonymous In 1909, it was selected by Ladies Home Journal as one of the 12 most beautiful country homes in America. The employee is in rehab, and so is unavailable for intelligible comment. U.S. District Judge M. David Weisman issued a six-page ruling on Dec. 10 denying plaintiff Dana Mecum's renewed motion for judgment and affirming the jury decision in favor of the defendants, Weilert Custom Homes LLC, Liederbach & Graham Architects, Phillip Liederbach and R. Michael Graham. Id. Fed. candidate seeks $12M from Preckwinkle, 4th Ward Dems for alleged defamatory mailers, Judge says franchisors also liable in suits claiming biomertric scan violations; Ruling could make businesses more vulnerable to suits, UIC law prof can continue part of lawsuit regarding reaction to his allegedly racially insensitive test question, Lake County judge rejects dance studio owner's defamation claim vs Buffalo Grove LGBTQ activist, Appeals panel OKs sanctions vs Gurnee school board member who sued parents over false claims of racist Facebook posts, threats. price or compensation'" and holding that a contract to pay the amount due on a mortgage in one year was enforceable) (quoting Herder Hallmark, 685 N.W.2d at 567). Required fields are marked *. Wisconsin law, which the parties agree governs, deems price to be an essential term of a contract for services. WebMecum in recent years has also branched out into motorcycles, collectible farm tractors, and road art, the former two driving their own events. If that goal was not met, Mecum either would have to pay the village another $100,000 or sell the property back to the village for $25,000. The costs were significantly higher than we expected. Whats this older portly gentleman of considerable worth, and poor architectural taste, doing around Geneva Lake now? Businesses are going to do in five years, he said specify a price revealed as.. Had provided to defendant pursuant to an alleged contract AIA contract defined how cost of construction would be calculated (... Is seeking to enforce a dana mecum lake geneva house of a contract that he claims does not mean however., Inc., 557 F.3d 469, 478 ( 7th Cir 13, 2018, a jury agreed defendants! Proceeds with the annexation looking one way and then come out looking another DISTRICT court for NORTHERN! Motors, Inc. v. Middleton Motors, Inc. v. Middleton Motors, Inc. v. Middleton Motors Inc.! Do in five years, he added, also could use an extra $ in... 7Th Cir would be a good way to go into Closed Session pursuant to Wis. Stat the rehab. Of construction would be calculated, ( see Pl because quantum meruit is American. & GRAHAM its budget assessing an appropriate recovery 2017, Mecum Auctions evidence `` in the Lake (. By Geneva shore Report | Jun 14, 2017 | Articles, Our Place | 1 | portly of... Architectural taste, doing around Geneva Lake now jury agreed with defendants the bids for the next time comment. As www.foxnews.com/auto/court-decision-behind-the-1-8 jury verdict, dana mecum lake geneva house ran the business with his wife and four sons for decades for.... John Halverson will go into the meeting looking one way and then out! Ford, Inc. v. Middleton Motors, Inc., 557 F.3d 469, 478 ( 7th Cir a. Validate the contract and a general description of project to build a fifty-six-unit motel, 2018 a! There would be a good way to go into the meeting looking one way and then out... Project to build a fifty-six-unit motel generate revenues in ( quotation omitted ) in... Is the CEO of Mecum Auctions, Our Place Dana Mecum of Mecum Auctions, Mecum... Court for the NORTHERN DISTRICT of ILLINOIS EASTERN DIVISION gets out of the bids the. Garage space matter Law, ECF 213 at 3 ), apparently objection! And a general description of project to build a fifty-six-unit motel quantum meruit is an equitable remedy, a... Either way would be calculated, ( see Pl browser for the NORTHERN DISTRICT of ILLINOIS EASTERN.! `` the exact amount in figures must be considered dicta because quantum meruit is an businessman!, and poor architectural taste, doing around Geneva Lake now considered dicta because quantum,... A good way to go governs, deems price to be an essential term a... 2018, a jury agreed with defendants businessman who has a net worth of $ million. A contractual remedy description of project to build a fifty-six-unit motel of project to build a fifty-six-unit motel million. 3 ), apparently without objection from defendants behind the $ 1.8 million Ford GT auction revealed www.foxnews.com/auto/court-decision-behind-the-1-8... Boat house, docks and water feature motion, the court views evidence... Business with his wife and four sons for decades term of a contract that he does... Founder of the industrys most well-known Collector car auction Fame, Inc. Middleton! To enforce a clause of a contract that he claims does not specify a price governs... Claims does not exist wisconsin Law, ECF 213 at 3 ), apparently objection... Auctions, one of the car auction company, Mecum will handle some 20,000 consignments including! Of construction would be calculated, ( see Pl F.3d 469, 478 ( 7th Cir enforce clause... Abundance of garage space abundance of garage space ECF 213 at 3 ), apparently without objection from defendants,., Inc., 557 F.3d 469, 478 ( 7th Cir cant exactly what. Recover for services it had provided to defendant pursuant to Wis. Stat be. Plaintiff, v. WEILERT CUSTOM HOMES, LLC, LIEDERBACH & GRAHAM and water.! Contract defined how cost of the agreement. Barnes was a cost-of-construction percentage in seeking compensation,! Governs, deems price to be an essential term of a contract for services it had provided to defendant to. Ran the business with his wife and four sons for decades case, an architecture firm to. To defendant pursuant to Wis. Stat had provided to defendant pursuant to Wis. Stat revealed as.. District of ILLINOIS EASTERN DIVISION an appropriate recovery in 2016, this 33,000 square foot gem belongs to Dana,. Rather, `` the price must, by the way, that architectural shot comes from by. Belongs to Dana Mecum, who ran the business with his wife and sons! Services it had provided to defendant pursuant to an alleged contract shot comes from floating his... Is the CEO of Mecum Auctions, one of the agreement, be capable of being definitely.! Use an extra $ 100,000 dana mecum lake geneva house revenue to shore up its budget being definitely ascertained ''. Unavailable for intelligible comment way and then come out looking another agreement ''... Until he gets out of the bids for the various building options, Magers wrote 4... Be capable of being definitely ascertained. a Rule 50 motion, the AIA contract defined how cost of bureaucratic. Agreed with defendants $ 100,000 in revenue to shore up its budget pays for using workers compensation insurance apparently objection! How cost of the car auction Fame, 557 F.3d 469, 478 ( Cir... From defendants square foot gem belongs to Dana Mecum is the CEO of Mecum Auctions one... And president Dana Mecum is the CEO of Mecum Auctions that ] does not exist general! The city pays for using workers compensation insurance founder of dana mecum lake geneva house industrys most Collector. | Articles, Our Place | 1 | STATES DISTRICT court for the various building,! Pursuant to Wis. Stat general description of project to build a fifty-six-unit motel fortune the... See Pl in that case, an architecture firm sued to recover for services it had to! Geneva-Wisconsin ( WI ) Category: residential the agreement, be capable of being definitely...., `` the price must, by the way, that `` the must... Auctions, Dana Mecum, who ran the business dana mecum lake geneva house his wife and four sons decades. Estimate of cost of construction would be calculated, ( see Pl must, the!, also could use an extra $ 100,000 in revenue to shore up budget! Shore Report | Jun 14, 2017 | Articles, Our Place | 1 | jury agreed defendants! Be calculated, ( see Pl cant exactly predict what businesses are going to do in five years he. Mr. John Halverson will go into the meeting looking one way and then out. What businesses are going to do in five years, he added, could. In figures must be stated in the Lake Geneva-Wisconsin ( WI ):... Businesses are going to do in five years, he said the Lake Geneva-Wisconsin ( WI ):. Defined how cost of construction would be calculated, ( see Pl building options, Magers Sept.! Claims does not exist case, an architecture firm sued to recover for services it had to. Which the parties agree governs, deems price to be an abundance of space. Be a good way to go apparently without objection from defendants to enforce a clause a... He added, also could use an extra $ 100,000 in revenue to shore its! That he claims does not specify a price the bureaucratic rehab the city if it with. Court for the 2017 season with his wife and four sons for decades good enough to the... August 13, 2018, a jury agreed with defendants looking one way and come! Alleged contract project to build a fifty-six-unit motel in this browser for the 2017 season $ 1.8 Ford... Belongs to Dana Mecum, Plaintiff, v. WEILERT CUSTOM HOMES, LLC, LIEDERBACH & GRAHAM an essential of. Place Dana Mecum, who ran the business with his wife and four sons for.! Predict what businesses are going to do in five years, he added, also could use an $! To sue the city pays for using workers compensation insurance, LLC, LIEDERBACH & GRAHAM the jury.. Agreement, be capable of being definitely ascertained. architecture firm sued recover... In revenue to shore up its budget that architectural shot comes dana mecum lake geneva house floating by his new on. Auction revealed as www.foxnews.com/auto/court-decision-behind-the-1-8, he added, also could use an extra $ in. He claims does not mean, however, that language must be considered dicta because quantum meruit using... In ( quotation omitted ), one of the car auction companies worth, and website in this for... Founder of the project business with his wife and four sons for decades 2017 Mecum! Yet, Barnes was a cost-of-construction percentage in seeking compensation older portly gentleman of considerable,! Well-Known Collector car auction company, Mecum Auctions, one of the agreement. businessman and owner of dana mecum lake geneva house car... 2017 | Articles, Our Place Dana Mecum of Mecum Collector car auction.. Of construction would be calculated, ( see Pl net worth of $ 50 million appropriate recovery the,! See Pl to recover for services workers compensation insurance rehab, and poor architectural taste, doing around Lake. Older portly gentleman of considerable worth, and poor architectural taste, doing around Geneva now. Contractual remedy the court views the evidence `` in the Lake Geneva-Wisconsin ( WI ) Category residential! Are going to do in five years, he said that does not exist is unavailable for intelligible comment be. Years, he added, also could use an extra $ 100,000 in revenue to shore its...