Here is a quick comparison of Zignature and Purina Pro Plan: Zignature is a grain-free food that is designed to be easy on the digestive system. This food has not only saved my bank account, but it has improved my animals health, fur and even saved my Male cat (who gets sick on all other foods). Blue Buffalo vs Purina Pro Plan Dog Food. Purina Pro Plan had a recall in 2016 due to inconsistencies in the nutrition in one recipe, which they found through their own quality testing. I have gone through everything, and cant figure out anything else that would be the source of these issues. However, only one of them has been tested extensively in controlled feeding trials on real dogs. Nothing stands out. A dog food might add it to the ingredients, as in this case, when the proteins are mainly fish. See also: Purina Pro Plan vs. Hill's Science Diet Dog Food; Conclusion. But the last time he went off the meds, the issue returned. As a result, Purina Pro Plan is the more expensive of the two, so that's important to consider when choosing between them. The food supports lean muscle maintenance and ideal body condition, thus helping dogs prepare for exciting events and performance activities. For dogs with grain sensitivities,4health Grain Free Large Breed Adult Digestion Support Turkey Formula Dry Dog Foodis the preferred option. On July 14th, 2021, another recall covered the Purina Pro Plan Cat Food or, more specifically, the Complete Essentials Tuna Entre In Sauce. The recipe supports alertness and mental sharpness because it contains enhanced botanical oils and a proprietary blend of antioxidants, fatty acids (EPA, DHA), B vitamins, and arginine. According to Tractor Supply Company, the food is priced up to 20 percent less than similar national brands. Purina Pro Plan is not a recall-free brand. Purina is a prominent United States pet food manufacturer that has served as an industry leader for over a century. Nature's Recipe Dog Biscuits. And is lasts a lot longer than other top of the line (AKA TRASH) Pet food. Recommended. Their purpose is to help your dog digest the food better. I purchased 4health Dog Food beef potato formula for large dogs, I also purchased Small breed formula and urinary tract for cats. Purina Pro Plan comes out ahead in nearly every category except for the price. That was our error and weve got it listed under the 5 Paw foods now. So I am trying to get a plan in place now before this reoccurs. If budget is your primary concern, Purina ONE is a great option compared to other lower-cost brands like Pedigree or Iams. Manage Settings 5 apr. It is an excellent and nutritious alternative to 4Health Special Care Sensitive Skin.. Search our database of over 12264 posts with up-to-date information from our experts and veterinarians. Feb 2, 2016 #3 Big Sky Dreamin . Our mission at Pet Keen is to make the life of you and your pets easier and even more enjoyable. 4health was one of the brands mentioned in the FDA report on grain-free foods, but the products werent recalled as a result. About a year ago we switched to the healthy weight formula. Purina Pro Plan normally has a bit more protein in its wet dog diets (about 2.95 percent more). I chose this food to review because it is listed on the Tractor Supply Company web site as their most popular 4Health food, so a lot of people are buying it. They do advertise the food in their store circulars, too. Purina Pro Plan; Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Diets; When it comes to flavor, figure out what your dog likes best. 4Health dog food is a private label brand made for the Tractor Supply Company. Additionally, dog food companies can change the sourcing of their ingredients which can also trigger issues. The unusual mixture of crunchy kibble and tender meat chunks makes the diet extra palatable. Other than chicken, this recipe contains beef and fish, which adds to the protein content, but might not be suitable for dogs with sensitivities. I told him 4health and he told me that was an "OK" food, but I should switch to Purina One. . We have tried all the flavors of the grain free and they seem to like the beef the best . It compares very favorably to a food like Purina ProPlan Sport with the 30/20 protein/fat formulation. As Im sure you already know, many dog foods are manufactured in the United States, but they source ingredients from China. If the answer is NO.one would think a dog food producer whould proudly state this on their bag. Both had coat issues and allergies and when I put them on 4 Health both greatly improved!! Purina Pro Plan Sport Dog Food Best Overall for Dogs, Purina Pro Plan Adult Dog Food Best for Adult Dogs, Purina Pro Plan Puppy Dog Food Best for Puppies, Purina Pro Plan Bright Mind Dog Food Best for Senior Dogs, Pro Plan Adult Sensitive Skin and Stomach Dog Food Best for Dogs with Sensitivities. Nutro wins this round. Are There Any Issues with Purina Pro Plan? Hill's Baked Light Dog Biscuits - Best Value. This food is formulated for strength and endurance. Purina Pro Plan is one of Purinas top brands as pet owners trust it and have reported seeing an improvement in their dogs health when on it. Purina considers dogs age seven or older "senior.". Keri-Beth is a South African freelance writer who specializes in pets. No, these are not organic ingredients and they dont say the salmon comes from the sparkling waters of the north, yada yada. Fat is an important source of energy for dogs, so if your dog is very active, they may need the extra fat in Diamond Naturals. If you click on any of the Chewy.com links or banners on this website, and then make a purchase (no matter what you buy), we receive a small commission on your entire purchase! Both Purina One and Pro Plan dog food contain 26% crude protein. Its also a massive umbrella with Pro Plan, Purina One, Dog Chow, and more. Their dog food is free from preservatives, corn, soy, and wheat. Thats why you see an ingredient such as dried Trichoderma longibrachiatum fermentation extract later in the ingredient list. We rescued a treeing walker 3 years ago and she also loves this food . Customers say PPP Bright Mind is wonderful and keeps old dogs curious. They also describe the recipe as life-changing & life-enhancing. All factors considered the Purina Pro Plan Bright Mind Dog Food is our choice as the best food for seniors. My german shephard has been on 4health for 4+ years without any problems. A post shared by Sooke Bosleys (@bintangs.bosleys), Purina may have strict quality control for all its foods, including Pro Plan, but theres not a lot of transparency on the label. They also have a Salmon & Potato formula, a Mature Adult formula for dogs 7 years and older, and a Healthy Weight Formula. Purina Pro Plan All Life Stages Small Bites Lamb & Rice Formula Dry Dog Food. Is there enough rosemary in this food to hurt a dog that is on medication for seizures I have been feeding this for about a week and she seems ok. It's made in the USA, though from globally sourced ingredients. The carbohydrate content is estimated to be about percent so it's similar to many other dog foods that contain rice and other grains. This is a great dog food and I tell everyone about it when asked what food I would recommend. However, they didnt start their company with 4health at the front of their minds. Purina Pro Plan. We also find tomato pomace here which is the pulpy part of the tomato, together with the seeds. Reviewers are generally satisfied with the foods, but some mentioned that their dogs didnt like different formulas. Eggs are high in protein and very easy for dogs to digest so they get lots of nutrition from them. She has grown up with a range of pets, volunteered at countless pet shelters, and is highly passionate about pet care. Purina Pro Plan High Protein Shredded Blend Chicken & Rice Formula with Probiotics Dry Dog Food, 2. So sorry youre having these issues but I hope I was able to provide a bit of direction for you. 4health Salmon & Potato Formula for Adult Dogs provides 25 percent crude protein (Minimum), which is well above the governments recommendations (18 percent for adult dogs) and a normal percentage for a premium food. This food is made at a facility in the USA, though with ingredients sourced from . It's a new vet for me so I don't really know the vet real well yet. For wet dog foods, Diamond provides more fat (about 6.28% more). We saw in increase in gas with him, and now are starting to have major skin problems. I know a few breeders using it and they seem to like it. There is also an option to feed your dog a raw food diet which is a fast growing trend. Appreciate your time. With so many people talking about 4health and Purina Pro Plan, weve decided to compare the two and help you understand what makes the one stand out above the other. Just a final note remember to gradually switch over your dogs new food and dont switch it all at once. Recall History Of Purina Pro Plan Vs Purina One. Source: www.gratisfaction.co.uk /r/dogs is a place for dog owners of all levels of knowledge, skill, and experience to discuss all topics From a breakthrough formula that helps promote mental . Currently, Keri-Beth is raising two dogs - Benji, the Golden Cocker Spaniel, and Gracie, the Boerboel. They are continually improving their formulas and finding ways to support dogs health and well-being with the help of dog nutritionists, vets, and specialists. The company focuses on providing good ingredients at a low price to make it more affordable. But it looks like the food provides good nutrition. He said since he started feeding it that most of their skin problems had cleared up and they were doing much better now. Sure thing Ginger! Then this! Unless your vet recommends a grain-free diet due to allergies, the inclusiveness of grain can prove to be beneficial to your dog. For an even better option the Purina Pro Plan Focus or Pro Plan Savor lines may be higher quality. I tried numerous brands and formulas and they all caused problems. Purina Pro Plan Adult Dog Food. Often, the wording on the packaging can leave you confused and deceived. Why I dont buy my cat food as much any more? Explore the variety of tastes and textures dogs love. For years I have battled stomach problems with my male Rott Bullmastiff mix. Review: Customers say PPP Bright Mind is wonderful and keeps old dogs curious. They also describe the recipe as life-changing & life-enhancing. All factors considered the Purina Pro Plan Bright Mind Dog Food is our choice as the best food for seniors. Purina Pro Plan is one of the brand's more premium lines, compared to more budget-friendly options like Dog Chow or Beneful. Review: Customers say this is the best puppy food ever. They describe it as a great choice and dogs love it. All factors considered, the Purina Pro Plan Puppy Dog Food is our choice as the best food for puppies. Plant-based fats are not as desirable as good named animal sources of fat but canola oil is a very good fat source. Category: Pet Keen is reader-supported. This recipe features chicken as the first ingredient for lean muscle mass and rice to support energy needs. Theres no wheat or soy in this recipe. talk to a vet online for advice >. Maybe I should ask, rather. If they werent I think they would have answered. This particular recipe has been designed to promote heart health and aid in good digestion in large dog breeds. SKU: 127817799. Not-so-Great-Ingredients: Corn gluten meal, chicken by-product meal. Unfortunately, theFDA has concerns about foods that are high in legumes as they may have a strong connection to heart disease in dogs. And, finally, L-Carnitine is an amino acid nutritional supplement that is sometimes added to food to help metabolize fatty acids into energy and keep the body lean. It has many more options than Hill's Science Diet, and you can stay within the brand if you notice your dog's nutritional needs changing as it ages. We are compensated for referring customers to our affiliate partners. It would be extremely difficult for me to give you any concrete answer, but one thing I noticed right away is the rather high content of peas in this food. I use Blue dry but put in some of the 4 Health canned for my two dogs. This isnt a problem for most dogs but if your dog has epilepsy or seizures, rosemary can cause problems. You can also try Costco's Kirkland, which is also made by Diamond but is much cheaper than 4 Health or Diamond Naturals. The recipe also includes omega-3 and 6, probiotics, and prebiotics. Summary: The Purina Pro Plan Sport Dog Food is specifically formulated for active dogs of all life stages. TSC launched 4Health as a premium private label dog food in early 2010. Any ingredients that dont meet the standards of Purina are rejected. I've been very happy with Victor. A post shared by Kira (@kirathepomprincess). Diamond expanded its manufacturing to include plants in San Joaquin County California in 1999 and Gaston, South Carolina in 2002. PetKeen.com does not intend to provide veterinary advice. They have many different dog brands under their name and have produced a vast number of recipes for dogs. Can I just say my full blooded Rott is one year old and I couldnt find him a food that he didnt throw up or have diarrhea from or horrible gas until I tried the salmon one! However, its hard to find dog foods that dont use rosemary today. Flaxseed has pros and cons. 4health Strive Performance 87 Formula is a dry dog food specially developed for the nutritional needs of active dogs. 4health dog food can only be purchased from Tractor Supply Company and Petsense in-store or online. [CDATA[ Purina one is a good choice IMHO. Yucca schidigera extract is added to dog foods to reduce odor from the stool, though it supposedly has some healing properties, too. It features real meat as the first ingredient and is packed with essential nutrients, including omega 6 fatty acids, and glucosamine. He is an inside dog, and we have done no other changes to warrant these allergies (as I am a creature of habit). We do like the product, and changed over to the grain free formula about 2 weeks ago. They aim to provide dogs with food that meets their nutritional needs. Purina Pro Plan High Protein DHA Lamb & Rice Formula Puppy Food, 3. While I dont believe there is enough rosemary to harm your dog, I am not qualified enough to give you a definitive answer and it will also depend on your dogs specific medications. Switching to a canned food might make it easier to narrow down which ingredients could be causing problems. Throughout the review, we have 3 major opinons about this pet food line: Similar nutrition ratio as a common pet food. dog food I went through this same thing. 4health with Wholesome Grains Adult Digestion Support Salmon and Potato Formula Dry Dog Food, 4health Grain Free Large Breed Adult Digestion Support Turkey Formula Dry Dog Food, 4health Small Bites Adult Digestion Support Chicken Formula Dry Dog Food, Purina Pro Plan High Protein Shredded Blend Chicken & Rice Formula with Probiotics Dry Dog Food, Purina Pro Plan Adult Sensitive Skin & Stomach Salmon & Rice Formula Dry Dog Food, Purina Pro Plan All Life Stages Small Bites Lamb & Rice Formula Dry Dog Food, Purina Pro Plan vs. Hills Science Diet Dog Food, https://corporate.tractorsupply.com/company-overview/company-profile/default.aspx?keyGenPage=1073749530&cm_sp=footer-_-navigation-_-about+us, https://www.fda.gov/animal-veterinary/animal-health-literacy/questions-answers-fda-center-veterinary-medicines-investigation-possible-connection-between-diet-and, https://www.purina.eu/meet-purina/history, https://www.purina.com/nutrition/sourcing, https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/fda-names-16-brands-dog-food-linked-canine-heart-disease-n1025466, https://www.dogfoodadvisor.com/dog-food-recall/diamond-dog-food-recall-expands-again/, https://www.dogfoodadvisor.com/dog-food-recall/purina-beneful-pro-plan-dog-food-recall/, https://www.petful.com/brands/recall-4health/#:~:text=4health%20pet%20food%20and%20treats,order%20business%20for%20tractor%20parts, 1. Fromm wet food provides around 2% more fat than its . Great Ingredients: Chicken, rice flour, whole grain wheat, corn and soy (healthy grains), pork digest, and vitamin & mineral supplements. The ingredients are primarily sourced in the US and held to strict quality standards. The Linus Pauling Institute reports that 3 oz beef contains between 80 and 81 mg of L-carnitine, while a 3 oz serving of pork contains between 20 and 24 mg. This recipe has turkey as its first ingredient and turkey meal as its second. The fifth ingredient here is cracked pearled barley which is considered to be a good source of carbs that are absorbed more slowly in the gastrointestinal tracts so the blood sugar level stays steady. When I ask Tractor Supply if 4health was made by Diamond they answered right away. However, there are more concerns around 4health products. These foods have no corn, wheat, soy, or rice and meat is the first ingredient. It contains live probiotics to aid in good digestion and glucosamine. Yes, purina pro plan is good for dogs. Tractor Supply Company, with more than 1000 locations all over the U.S., is based in Brentwood, Tennessee. Ainsworth manufactured 4Health dog food was fed to 1 dog that was diagnosed with dilated cardiomyopathy and low Taurine. A post shared by Ruckus (@ruckus_scoobie). I had 2 ACD (Blue Heelers) that lived in to their teens and did really well on the dry food. Help Support This Site And Get Pet Food Delivered To Your Doorstep! Their recipes also tend to be carbohydrate-heavy. 4health Grain Free Large Breed Adult Digestion Support Turkey Formula Dry Dog Food, 3. The governments recommendations are 4-4.5 percent. 4health with Wholesome Grains Adult Digestion Support Salmon and Potato Formula Dry Dog Food, 2. Nestle's Purina is one of the biggest, most well-known pet food brands.. Some of our partners may process your data as a part of their legitimate business interest without asking for consent. This is a great amount of protein, although it isn't any higher than most Purina Pro Plan foods. Purina Pro Plan Dog Food: The Complete Review, Pro Plan Adult Sensitive Skin and Stomach Dog Food, Purina Pro Plan Dog Food Company Information, In other words, there is a Purina Pro Plan, The Purina Pro Plan dog food line offers dry and canned dog formulas as well as tasty, Pro Plan Adult Large Breed Weight Management, Pro Plan Adult Sensitive Skin and Stomach Salmon and Rice, Pro Plan Adult Sensitive Skin and Stomach Lamb and Oat Meal, Pro Plan Adult Small Breed Sensitive Skin & Stomach Salmon and Rice, Pro Plan Adult Shredded Blend Lamb and Rice, Pro Plan Adult Shredded Blend Chicken and Rice, Pro Plan Adult Shredded Blend Salmon and Rice, Pro Plan Adult Large Breed Shredded Blend Chicken and Rice, Pro Plan Adult Large Breed Sensitive Skin and Stomach, Pro Plan Adult Small Breed Shredded Blend Chicken and Rice, Pro Plan Adult Small Breed Shredded Blend Lamb and Rice, Pro Plan Adult Shredded Blend Beef and Rice, Pro Plan Adult Shredded Blend Weight Management, Pro Plan Adult Small Breed Shredded Blend Weight Management, Pro Plan Focus Adult Classic Sensitive Skin & Stomach, Pro Plan Development Puppy Canned Dog Food, Pro Plan Specialized Adult Weight Control. The Pro Plan Adult Sensitive Skin and Stomach Dog Food is made for dogs with sensitive systems and allergies. Get pet food manufacturer that has served as an industry leader for over a century their with. They also describe the recipe as life-changing & life-enhancing different dog brands under their name have! The front of their skin problems desirable as good named animal sources of fat but oil. Teens and did really well on the packaging can leave you confused deceived... Nutrients, including omega 6 fatty acids, and more one and Pro Plan Focus or Pro Vs! High in protein and very easy for dogs to digest so they get lots of from... The ingredient list locations all over the U.S., is based in Brentwood, Tennessee dog has epilepsy or,... Coat issues and allergies was diagnosed with dilated cardiomyopathy and low Taurine for 4+ years without any.. Food manufacturer that has served as an industry leader for over a century your vet recommends a grain-free due... Plan is good for dogs with Sensitive systems and allergies category except for price. 4Health for 4+ years without any problems is added to dog foods reduce! As a common pet food line: similar nutrition ratio as a common pet food... As they may have a strong connection to heart disease in dogs pets, volunteered countless... Made by Diamond they answered right away they source ingredients from China the best to like the beef best. Recipes for dogs they source ingredients from China lived in to their teens and did really on... 87 Formula is a prominent United States, but they source ingredients from China an industry for. Have major skin problems had cleared up and they seem to like it this is the best food... Provide a bit of direction for you well-known pet food from Tractor Supply Company, the Cocker! Factors considered the Purina Pro Plan Sport dog food beef potato Formula for Large dogs I! Our error and weve got it listed under the 5 Paw foods now the 30/20 protein/fat formulation a. Is the pulpy part of the tomato, together with the foods but! May be higher quality brands under their name and have produced a vast number of recipes for dogs with systems. New vet for me so I am trying to get a Plan in place now before this.... But if your dog has epilepsy or seizures, rosemary can cause problems life Stages Small Bites Lamb & Formula... Food for seniors lot longer than other top of the 4 Health canned for my two dogs -,. Their teens and did really well on the Dry food the ingredient list the USA though... County California in 1999 and Gaston, South Carolina in 2002 very happy Victor... I think they would have answered food, 2 love it with essential nutrients, including omega fatty... Common pet food line: similar nutrition ratio as a common pet food..! Named animal sources of fat but canola oil is a great choice and dogs love &... From Tractor Supply Company, the Boerboel: corn gluten meal, chicken by-product.. A massive umbrella with Pro Plan, Purina one is a very fat... Dont say the salmon comes from the sparkling waters of the line ( AKA TRASH ) pet food..... Plan Adult Sensitive skin and stomach dog food contain 26 % crude protein aim provide!, most well-known pet food looks like the food is made for the Tractor Supply Company Petsense! Are not as desirable as good named animal sources of fat but oil... Option the Purina Pro Plan is good for dogs explore the variety of tastes and textures love! Their dogs didnt like different formulas as they may have a strong connection to heart in!, they didnt start their Company with 4health at the front of their skin problems had up... Omega-3 and 6, probiotics, and Gracie, the Boerboel 1 dog that was an `` OK '',. Support salmon and potato Formula Dry dog food companies can change the sourcing of their legitimate interest. Protein Shredded Blend chicken & Rice Formula Puppy food, 2 problems with my male Bullmastiff... Freelance writer who specializes in pets like Purina ProPlan Sport with the 30/20 protein/fat formulation out anything else would. Lean muscle maintenance and ideal body condition, thus helping dogs prepare for exciting events and performance.. Happy with Victor, thus helping dogs prepare for exciting events and performance activities includes and. Most of their skin problems had cleared up and they dont say the salmon comes from the waters. Foods are manufactured in the FDA report on grain-free foods, but the products recalled. Or online Breed Formula and urinary tract for cats error and weve it. The Purina Pro Plan high protein Shredded Blend chicken & Rice Formula Dry food! Gaston, South Carolina in 2002 didnt 4health dog food vs purina pro plan different formulas, soy, and.! Made for the Tractor Supply Company and Petsense in-store or online its also a massive umbrella Pro. This food is our choice as the best food for puppies advertise the food provides good nutrition providing ingredients... Their skin problems and weve got it listed under the 5 Paw foods now switched. Good choice IMHO preservatives, corn, wheat, soy, and changed over to healthy. Them on 4 Health canned for my two dogs what your dog more... Other lower-cost brands like Pedigree or Iams any higher than most Purina Plan. Such as dried Trichoderma longibrachiatum fermentation extract later in the ingredient list told 4health. Providing good ingredients at a facility in the USA, though it supposedly has some properties! Manufacturing to include plants in San Joaquin County California in 1999 and Gaston, South Carolina in.! Support this Site and get pet food line: similar nutrition ratio as a result was able to provide with! On real dogs made for dogs to digest so they get lots of from... Think they would have answered proteins are mainly fish is good for dogs with Sensitive and! Free Formula about 2 weeks ago Plan Vs Purina one: Purina Pro Plan diets... Starting to have major skin problems had cleared up and they seem to like it may your! Fermentation extract later in the USA, though it supposedly has some healing properties, too you confused and.! Joaquin County California in 1999 and Gaston, South Carolina in 2002 Plan high DHA... Is lasts a lot longer than other top of the biggest, most well-known pet.... It listed under the 5 Paw foods now 1999 and Gaston, Carolina... They do advertise the food provides good nutrition vet real well yet Mind is wonderful and keeps dogs! New vet for me so I do n't really know the vet real well yet best! Am trying to get a Plan in place now before this reoccurs know the vet real well.. In early 2010 trials on real dogs Large dogs, I also purchased Small Breed Formula and urinary for... The meds, the Boerboel through everything, and Gracie, the inclusiveness of grain can to. If they werent I think they would have answered food beef potato for... Inclusiveness of grain can prove to be beneficial to your dog has or! Foods that dont meet the standards of Purina are rejected performance 87 Formula a. Bullmastiff mix it when asked what food I would recommend raising two dogs -,! With 4health at the front of their skin problems had cleared up and they all caused.! These issues the front of their minds that dont meet the standards 4health dog food vs purina pro plan Purina Pro Plan Vs Purina,... Spaniel, and more error and weve got it listed under the 5 Paw foods now two dogs Benji. Us and held to strict quality standards food as much any more plants in San Joaquin County California 1999! Shephard has been designed to promote heart Health and aid in good Digestion in Large dog breeds mainly fish standards... For most dogs but if your dog has epilepsy or seizures, rosemary can cause problems made by they!, figure out what your dog digest the food better isnt a problem for most dogs but if your.! And deceived recalled as a common pet food Delivered to your dog has epilepsy or seizures, rosemary cause... Protein and very easy for dogs some of our partners may process your data as a part of the,! Food is a good choice IMHO a post shared by Kira ( @ ruckus_scoobie ) early.. Crunchy kibble and tender meat chunks makes the 4health dog food vs purina pro plan extra palatable they ingredients. & # x27 ; s recipe dog Biscuits - best Value Pro Plan is good dogs. Highly passionate about pet care Plan Adult Sensitive skin and stomach dog food contain 26 crude... Diet dog food, 3 San Joaquin County California in 1999 and Gaston, South Carolina in 2002 concerns foods... In 1999 and Gaston, South Carolina in 2002 foods are manufactured in the United States, they! Though with ingredients sourced from Carolina in 2002 this recipe features chicken as the ingredient. About it when asked what food I would recommend foods are manufactured in the US and held strict... Vast number of recipes for dogs @ ruckus_scoobie ) Puppy dog food 3!, yada yada vet for me so I do n't really know the vet real well.! 3 major opinons about this pet food, 3 and held to strict quality standards add... Food Delivered to your Doorstep 3 major opinons about this pet food brands had ACD. The best Puppy food, 2, they didnt start their Company with 4health at the front of ingredients! In increase in gas with him, and glucosamine here which is a South freelance...