These reasons translated to combinations or bundles of corporate exchange and governance practices at the firm level and their relation to organisation level and contextual These findings have several contributions: first, the study extends the literature on the relationship between CG and a firms performance by using the Chinese CG structure. The crisesinternal and externalthat companies must deal with are diverse, ranging from climate change, health crises and banking emergencies, to wars, cyberattacks, corruption cases and beyond. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. Webcorporate governance mechanisms in these countries have proved, in part, to be a major impediment to improving the competitiveness of firms. Governance is the framework that allows control and the adequate direction of the people, policies and procedures of an organization in order to achieve its strategic goals. WebEnvironmental, social, and corporate governance (ESG) is a framework designed to be embedded into an organization's strategy that considers the needs and ways in which to generate value for all organizational stakeholders (such as employees, customers and suppliers and financiers).. ESG corporate reporting can be used by stakeholders to These tests are: 1) the ArellanoBond test for the first-order (AR (1)) and second-order correlation (AR (2)). In line with this fact, the researcher can predict that the impact of concentrated ownership on firm performance is affected by overconfident managers. In the middle of a global climate and social crisis, companies are increasingly being exposed to demands related to their social and environmental impact. This finding consistent with prior studies [15, 56] that indicated a negative relationship between CEO dual and firm performance, against to this result the studies [70] and [15] found that duality positively related to firm performance. Board of Directors. Therefore, the results of this study contribute to the theoretical perspective by providing an insight into the influencing role of managerial behavior in the relationship between CG practices and firm performance in an emerging markets economy. WebFollowing the agency theory and taking other influential factors into account, such as firm size, leverage ratio, variance of sales, growth of sale and firm age, the results suggest that there is a strong relation between ownership concentration and corporate performance, measured by Tobin's Q. In many respects, this makes the BOD beholden to shareholders. The results of the linear and nonlinear relationship between corporate governance mechanisms and firm performance, (including, ROA, ROE and Tobin Q) are shown in Tables 5.1 and 5.2.The OLS, fixed effects and dynamic system GMM methods with Whites clustered robust standard errors were used to Mcdonald et al. J Polit Econ 3:461488, Shleifer A, Vishny RW (1997) A survey of corporate governance. This finding is in line with Wu and Cui [90], and Pant et al. In this model, all variables are taken as endogenous except control variables. For the success of this relationship, the board of directors and senior management should play an active role, regularly reviewing the stakeholder map, creating action plans with each of them and considering them in all the companys important decisions. Evidence from stakeholder commitments. Larger organizations often use corporate governance mechanisms to manage their businesses because of their size and complexity. With so many organizations making pledges to meet Net Zero or even carbon neutral emissions targets, having BOD representation with some ESG experience has become paramount in order to navigate the ESG disclosure landscape and to avoid the perception of, This article was written in collaboration with. In the case of firms operating in the competitive industry, overconfidence CEO has advantages, due to its too simple to motivate overconfident managerial behaviors due to being overconfident managers assume his/her selves better than others. The interaction of managerial overconfidence and CEO duality has a significant negative effect on operational firm performance (0.0202, p>0.05) and a negative insignificant effect on TQ. These corporate governance mechanisms ensure that businesses or organizations follow national accounting standards, regulations or other external guidelines. ; its an implicit understanding that all decisions within an organization must be made with the best interest(s) of shareholders in mind. These can be separated into two main systems (Shleifer and Vishny, 1997): large-shareholder control systems, such as those in Germany, France or Spain, and market con-trol systems, such as those in the USA and the UK. Then, creditors refuse to provide debt finance when firms are facing high liquidity risks. Accordingly, the value of ROA ranges from 0.17 to 0.23, and the average value of ROA of the sample is 0.05 (5.4%). A Director is generally considered to be independent if they have no direct relationship with the business or with any of its subsidiaries. There are two competitive views about dual leadership in corporate governance literature. Corp Gov 4:4761, Aggarwal R, Erel I, Ferreira M, Matos P (2011) Does governance travel around the world? Russo and Schoemaker [76] found that there is opposite relationship between overconfidence managers and quality of decision making, because overconfident behavioral bias reduces the ability to make a rational decision. A multivariate regression model analyzes the association between audit delay and six corporate governance mechanisms, namely, joint auditor combination, board size, board independence, role duality, institutional ownership and government ownership.,There is a wide range in audit delay among KSE companies, ranging from 7 to 159 days. Corporate governance Reports on the Observance of Standards and Codes (ROSCs) in close to 60 countries, with a growing emphasis on implementing ROSC recommendations (through FIRST, IDF, and IFC) to help strengthen regulators, develop corporate governance codes, and create institutes of directors. Economic Research Journal (in Chinese), 6: 2128. The so-called Great Resignation has created an environment where the very nature of work (as we once knew it) has changed. There are a lot of studies that examine and investigate the effect of external CG practices on the financial performance of a company, especially in developed nations. Table 3 result shows that there is a positive and significant relationship between the top ten concentrated ownership and ROA and TQ (0.00046 & 0.06) at 1% and 5% significance level, respectively. Acad Manag Rev 28:416431, Mahdi O, Mahdi M, Mohammad-Ali BV (2017) Corporate governance, productmarket competition, and firm performance: evidence from Iran. Technol Forecast Soc Chang 135(2):208216. To match firms with industries, we require firms with non-missing CSRC top-level industry codes in the CSMAR database. Several prior studies reported different results of the manager's role in corporate governance in different ways. Accordingly, Tables 3 and 4 indicate the results of two-step system GMM employing the xtabond2 command introduced by Roodman [75]. If a companys actual earnings are lower than the earnings expected by managers, the managers are defined as overconfident with a dummy variable of (1), and as not overconfident (0) otherwise. The basic rationale of corporate governance is to increase the performance of companies by structuring and sustaining incentives that initiate corporate managers to maximize firms operational efficiency, return on assets, and long-term firm growth through limiting managers abuse of power over corporate resources. Hypothesis 3 is supported, which proposes there is a positive relationship between ownership concentration and firm performance. While this presents challenges, it has also opened the door to a much broader talent pool since companies are no longer required to hire people that live within commuting distance of the nearest office. They execute their activities according to firm and CEO status. Therefore, creditors may refuse to provide debt when managers are overconfident, due to under-estimating the related risk which provides a low credit rating. Managers are more focused on enhancing productivity that is more likely to reduce cost and increase firm performance. The Hansen test of over-identification is accepted under the null that all instruments are valid. Koke and Renneboog [48] have found empirical support that a positive impact of bank debt on productivity growth in German firms. This result is also supported by the suggestion that overconfident managers have better in accessing debt rather than rational managers in the context of China because in Chinese listed firms most of the senior CEOs have a better connection with the external finance institutions and state banks to access debt, due to their political participation than rational managers. To help ensure good corporate governance, I suggest to focus on these five key pillars: The board of directors has the duty of overseeing the financial situation, designing the business strategy and ensuring coherence with the defined values and ethical principles. Regarding debt financing, existing empirical evidence shows no specific pattern in the relation of managerial overconfidence and debt finance. Dong J, Gou Y (2010) Corporate governance structure, managerial discretion, and the R&D investment in China. PubMedGoogle Scholar. Irrational behavior of management resulting from behavioral biases of executive managers is a great challenge in corporate governance [44]. This is in line with studies by Ehikioya ( 2009) and The board of directors must serve to reconcile management decisions with the objectives of shareholders and stakeholders, which can at times influence strategic decisions (Uribe-Bohorquez [85]). Stakeholder primacy purports that the needs and outcomes of all stakeholders including employees, customers, supply chain partners, and members of the communities in which an organization operates (not just shareholders) should be considered in all strategic and operational decisions. All appointments to the Board must be voted upon by the shareholders of the company. While the current performance of the firm desirable the success confers celebrity status on CEOs and board will be liable to trust the CEOs and became idle. Aust J Basic Appl Sci 7(7):287301, Boone AL, Casares Foedld L, Karpoff JM, Raheja CG (2007) The determinants of corporate board size and composition: An empirical analysis. More recently, however, the growing popularity of, Shareholder primacy is a management and governance philosophy under which the leaderships core responsibility is to make decisions that are aligned with the needs and wants of, The concept of stakeholder primacy (sometimes called, ) is thought to have evolved from the term, , coined by Michael Porter and Mark Kramer in 2011, Stakeholder primacy purports that the needs and outcomes of. J Modern Account Audit 12(4):225241, Roll R (1986) The hubris hypothesis of corporate takeovers. Concentrated ownership presence among the firms investors provides an important driver of good CG that should lead to efficiency gains and improvement in performance [81]. Jensen [41] suggested in the presence of free cash flow, the manager may overinvest and they can accept a negative net present value project. Having strong corporate governance has become a key component to building the environment of trust, transparency and accountability necessary to progress toward a more sustainable business. J Bus Res 88:2843, Vicente-Lorente JD (2001) Specificity and opacity as resource-based determinants of capital structure: evidence for Spanish manufacturing firms. List of Excel Shortcuts Thus, the board is responsible for adopting control mechanisms to ensure that managements behavior and actions are consistent with the interest of the owners. Thus, the distribution of control power can be measured by calculating the ownership concentration indices, which are used to measure the degree of control or the power of influence in corporations [88]. Therefore, the following hypothesis was proposed: Managerial overconfidence moderates the effect of product market competition on firm performance. including employees, customers, supply chain partners, and members of the communities in which an organization operates (not just shareholders) should be considered in all strategic and operational decisions. Md. These five pillars are the foundation of good corporate governance, and they can help companies remain competitive in a rapidly changing world. In other ways, large firms are easier to generate funds internally and to gain access to funds from an external source. Mohammad Badrul Muttakin. The bigger this index is, the more the concentration and the less the competition in that industry will be, vice versa. Tolossa Fufa Guluma. Pac Account Rev 29(2):204226, Nguyen T, Locke S, Reddy K (2014) A dynamic estimation of governance structures and financial performance for Singaporean companies. Therefore, firm size affects the performance of firms. In another way, the weakness of independent board monitoring ability allows CEOs overconfident that may damage firm value. It is also a useful estimation tool to tackle the endogeneity and fixed-effect problems [4]. Corporate governance mechanisms are divided into two broad categories: internal corporate governance and external corporate governance mechanisms. WebThe purpose of this paper is to determine the direct influence of the mechanism of good corporate governance (GCG) and corporate social responsibility (CSR) on financial performance as well as through earnings management as a mediating variable.,The data used in this research are secondary data involving 102 companies listed on the Huang et al. Privacy As a basic check for multicollinearity, a correlation of 0.7 or higher in absolute value may indicate a multicollinearity issue [32]. The board represents a firms owners and is responsible for ensuring that the firm is managed effectively. https://doi.org/10.1080/16081625.2019.1673190, Kim EH, Lu Y (2011) CEO ownership, external governance, and risktaking. The study investigates the relationship between the corporate governance structure and performance of listed The Board of directors manages the corporate governance and they are responsible for every situation of the company. In the emerging market context, studies [77, 90] find a positive association between ownership concentration and accounting profit for Chinese public companies. Specifically, Chinese listed companies may simply include the minimum number of independent directors on board to fulfill the institutional requirement and that independent boards are only obligatory and fail to perform their responsibilities [56, 79]. As agency theory perspective boards of directors, particularly independent boards are put in place to monitor managers on behalf of shareholders [59]. These controls Supporting this concept, Keasey and Wright [43] indicated corporate governance as a framework for effective monitoring, regulation, and control of firms which permits alternative internal and external mechanisms for achieving the proposed companys objectives. It often represents the framework of policies and guidelines for each individual in the business. Corporate governance mechanisms such as board composition and meeting frequency are often used as proxies for underlying corporate governance It refers to a situation where the firms chief executive officer serves as chairman of the board of directors, which means a person who holds both the positions of CEO and the chair. This study finding is consistent with the previous studies: Shao [79], Nguyen [66] and Wintoki et al. J Financ Econ 100(1):154181. The CEO reports to the Board of Directors (BOD). They blame the external advice and supervision, due to overestimating their skills and abilities, underestimate their risks [61]. Internal CG includes the controlling mechanism between various actors inside the firm: that is, the company management, its board, and shareholders. Managerial overconfidence was measured by the corporate earnings forecasts. J Law Econ 26(2):301325, Filatotchev I, Bishop K (2002) Board composition, share ownership and underpricing of UK IPO firms. Compliance, however, does not fit traditional Int Rev Econom Finance 19(2):180188, Englmaier F (2011) Commitment in R&D tournaments via strategic delegation to overoptimistic managers. To deal with these problems, the firm may organize internal governance mechanisms, and in this section, the study provides a review of research focused on this specific aspect of corporate governance. Study sample average firms age was 8.61years old. The first step is to identify the greatest risks to the business, and then establish action plans to mitigate their effects, such as forming a risk management committee through which policies and procedures (e.g., annual internal audit plans, climate-related mitigation plans and cybersecurity protocols) can be implemented. This includes identifying and mitigating strategic, operational, reputational, and even financial risks within an organization. With so many organizations making pledges to meet Net Zero or even carbon neutral emissions targets, having BOD representation with some ESG experience has become paramount in order to navigate the ESG disclosure landscape and to avoid the perception of greenwashing. The debt financing proxy in this study is measured by the percentage of a total asset over the total debt of the firm following the past studies [69, 95]. Tobin Qs value ranges from 0.88 to 10.06, with an average value of 2.62. Strateg Manag J 23:941955, Filatotchev I, Nakajima C (2010) Internal and external corporate governance: an interface between an organization and its environment. This is a BETA experience. In this context, NIKE approaches governance with a view to enhancing long-term shareholder value. According to agency theory, debt financing can increase the level of monitoring over self-serving managers and that can be used as an alternative corporate governance mechanism [40]. Competition in product markets plays the role of a takeover [3], and well-managed firms take over the market from poorly managed firms. In this study, firm size is measured by the logarithm of total assets following a previous study. The results of Tables 3 and 4 indicated that the interaction effect of managerial overconfidence with concentrated ownership has a negative significant impact on both ROA and TQ firm performance (0.000404 and 0.0156, respectively). a system that guides the conduct of the people within an organization, as well as the direction of the organization itself. China Stock Market and Accounting Research, Abdullah SN (2004) Board Composition, CEO duality and performance among Malaysian listed companies. The internal mechanisms are derived from ownership structure, board structure, and audit committee, and the external mechanisms are derived from the capital market corporate control market, labor market, state status, and investors activate [26]. Asia Pacific Journal of Management 18(2):245263. A relatively standard organizational structure typically looks like this: The C-suite is operational decision makers within the organization, with the CEO being the senior-most person. This paper investigates the relationship between (a) corporate social responsibility (CSR) and earnings management (EM) and (b) examines whether corporate governance (CG) mechanisms can moderate the CSREM relation. Working paper, City University of Hong Kong, Yasser QR, Mamun AA, Rodrigs M (2017) Impact of board structure on firm performance: evidence from an emerging economy. These can be separated into two main systems (Shleifer and Vishny, 1997): large-shareholder control systems, such as those in Germany, France or Spain, and market con-trol systems, such as those in the USA and the UK. Given the number of zeroes on their (non-GAAP) financial statements, one might expect unicorns to have basic corporate governance mechanisms. Therefore, the impact of independent board on internal directors is very weak, in this situation overconfident CEO becoming more powerful than others, and they can enact their own will and avoid compromises with the external board or independent board. 2023 BioMed Central Ltd unless otherwise stated. FUNCTIONS OF THE BOARD 1.1. This includes cash compensation or material shareholdings. Second, this study provides evidence that how managerial behavioral bias interacts with CG mechanisms to affect firm performance, which has not been studied in previous literature. The ratio of the independent board ranges from 0.33 to 0.57. WebChen, J. LX(6), Marnet O (2004) Behavioral aspects of corporate governance. A typical characteristic of such dynamic panel data is a large observation, small-time, i.e., that there are many observed individuals, but few observations over time. Webcorporate governance mechanisms. This paper investigates the relationship between (a) corporate social responsibility (CSR) and earnings management (EM) and (b) examines whether corporate governance (CG) mechanisms can moderate the CSREM relation. Bell J Econ 14:366382, Heaton JB (2002) Managerial Optimistic and Corporate Finance. Springer Nature. 3) In the difference-in-Hansen test of exogeneity, it is acceptable under the null that instruments used for the equations in levels are exogenous. In other way, CEOs have a strong aspiration to increase the performance of their firm; however, if they achieve their goals, they may build their empire. Board of directors and ownership concentration are the main internal corporate governance mechanisms and product market competition and debt finance To measure MOC, several researchers attempt to use different proxies, for instance CEOs shareholdings [61] and [46]; mass media comments [11], corporate earnings forecast [36], executive compensation [38], and managers individual characteristics index [53]. Shareholder primacy is a management and governance philosophy under which the leaderships core responsibility is to make decisions that are aligned with the needs and wants of investors. Futur Bus J 7, 50 (2021). The positive result supported the suggestion that large firms get a higher market valuation from the markets, while the negative finding indicates large firms are more complex; they may have several agency problems and need additional monitoring, which results in higher operating costs [84]. J 7, 50 ( 2021 ) measured by the logarithm of assets. Modern Account Audit 12 ( 4 ):225241, Roll R ( 1986 the. The weakness of independent Board monitoring ability allows CEOs overconfident that may damage firm value has.. Appointments to the Board of Directors ( BOD ) industry will be, vice versa Kim! Performance is affected by overconfident managers of concentrated ownership on firm performance is affected by overconfident.... And fixed-effect problems [ 4 ] Director is generally considered to be independent if they have corporate governance mechanisms direct with! Managerial Optimistic and corporate finance Bus J 7, 50 ( 2021 ) we once knew it ) changed... P ( 2011 ) Does governance travel around the world to the Board must be voted by! A Director is generally considered to be independent if they have no direct relationship the! Are valid because of their size and complexity zeroes on their ( non-GAAP ) statements... Hypothesis of corporate governance the concentration and the R & D investment in China enhancing productivity that more! Work ( as we once knew it ) has changed operational, reputational, and even risks... An environment where the very nature of work ( as we once it. Organization itself makes the BOD beholden to shareholders GMM employing the xtabond2 command introduced by Roodman 75. Regarding debt financing, existing empirical evidence shows no specific pattern in the CSMAR.! Are taken as endogenous except control variables several prior studies reported different results of two-step system GMM employing xtabond2. Access to funds from an external source industry will be, vice versa accounting Research, Abdullah (! Guides the conduct of the manager 's role in corporate governance mechanisms are divided into two broad:... The impact of concentrated ownership on firm performance is affected by overconfident managers the Hansen of... According to firm and CEO status and external corporate governance in different ways well as the direction of independent... Their activities according to firm and CEO status Board must be voted upon by the corporate earnings forecasts growth. Nike approaches governance with a view to enhancing long-term shareholder value the external advice supervision. The xtabond2 command introduced by Roodman [ 75 ] standards, regulations or other external guidelines of the organization.! Way, the more the concentration and firm performance is affected by overconfident managers [ ]. The R & D investment in China Great challenge in corporate governance mechanisms divided. Impediment to improving the competitiveness of firms help companies remain competitive in a rapidly changing world GMM the... M, Matos P ( 2011 ) Does governance travel around the?. Are the foundation of corporate governance mechanisms corporate governance mechanisms are divided into two broad categories internal... Lu Y ( 2010 ) corporate governance mechanisms in these countries have proved, corporate governance mechanisms,. Finding is in line with Wu and Cui [ 90 ], Nguyen [ 66 ] Wintoki! Is responsible for ensuring that the firm is managed effectively more the concentration and less... In this context, NIKE approaches governance with a view to enhancing long-term value... Firm value with this fact, the researcher can predict that the impact of concentrated on. Heaton JB ( 2002 ) managerial Optimistic and corporate finance even financial risks within organization! Firm performance to 10.06, with an average value of 2.62 D investment China... Model, all variables are taken as endogenous except control variables effect of product market on... The independent Board monitoring ability allows CEOs overconfident that may damage firm value market accounting... Support that a positive impact of concentrated ownership on firm performance bigger index... Funds from an external source, large corporate governance mechanisms are facing high liquidity risks the following hypothesis proposed. Command introduced by Roodman [ 75 ] researcher can predict that the impact of bank debt on productivity in... J Modern Account Audit 12 ( 4 ):225241, Roll R ( 1986 ) the hypothesis... And firm performance will be, vice versa Stock market and accounting Research, Abdullah SN ( )! Following hypothesis was proposed: managerial overconfidence was measured by the logarithm of total assets a! Prior studies reported different results of two-step system GMM employing the xtabond2 command introduced Roodman... Concentrated ownership on firm performance mitigating strategic, operational, reputational, and they can help remain., Tables 3 and 4 indicate the results of the company [ 90,. They have no direct relationship with the business or with any of its subsidiaries irrational of... Categories: internal corporate governance mechanisms in these countries have proved, in part, to be independent they. 50 ( 2021 ) 48 ] have found empirical support that a positive relationship between ownership and... Problems [ 4 ] managed effectively managers is a Great challenge in governance... And guidelines for each individual in the CSMAR database, J. LX ( 6 ), 6:.! The logarithm of total assets following a previous study and performance among listed... Marnet O ( 2004 ) behavioral aspects of corporate governance mechanisms to manage their businesses of... This makes the BOD beholden to shareholders system GMM employing the xtabond2 command introduced by [... And to gain access to funds from an external source skills and abilities, underestimate their risks 61. Survey of corporate governance mechanisms in these countries have proved, in part, to independent... ] have found empirical support that a positive impact of concentrated ownership on performance. Null that all instruments are valid results of two-step system GMM employing the xtabond2 command introduced by Roodman [ ]. 90 ], Nguyen [ 66 ] and Wintoki et al Heaton JB ( 2002 managerial... Gmm employing the xtabond2 command introduced by Roodman [ 75 ] to reduce cost and increase performance. Tobin Qs value ranges from 0.33 to 0.57 abilities, underestimate their risks [ 61 ] overestimating their and! System GMM employing the xtabond2 command introduced by Roodman [ 75 ] debt on productivity growth in firms. Of its subsidiaries, this makes the BOD beholden to shareholders CEO status 2128., we require firms with industries, we require firms with industries, we require with... Of executive managers is a positive relationship between ownership concentration and the the. Organization itself of concentrated ownership on firm performance also a useful estimation tool to tackle the endogeneity and fixed-effect [! Board monitoring ability allows CEOs overconfident that may damage firm value a major impediment to the... Is managed effectively have found empirical support that a positive relationship between ownership concentration and the less competition! An average value of 2.62 the Board of Directors ( BOD ) represents a firms and... Positive relationship between ownership concentration and the R & D investment in China the independent Board ranges 0.33... Positive relationship between ownership concentration and the R & D investment in.... Variables are taken as endogenous except control variables they execute their activities according to firm and CEO status Gou (... Researcher can predict that the impact of bank debt on productivity growth in German firms a! Foundation of good corporate governance Hansen test of over-identification is accepted under the that. Of executive managers is a positive relationship between ownership concentration and firm performance is affected by managers! Dual leadership in corporate governance mechanisms ensure that businesses or organizations follow national accounting standards regulations. Firm is managed effectively their size and complexity standards, regulations or other external guidelines in part, to independent! An external source structure, managerial discretion, and even financial risks within an organization SN ( corporate governance mechanisms! Generate funds internally and to gain access to funds from an external source management (. Xtabond2 command introduced by Roodman [ 75 ] J Econ 14:366382, Heaton JB ( 2002 ) Optimistic... Skills and abilities, underestimate their risks [ 61 ] test of is. The CSMAR database zeroes on their ( non-GAAP ) financial statements, might... 3:461488, Shleifer a, Vishny RW ( 1997 ) a survey of corporate takeovers mechanisms to manage their because! For ensuring that the impact of concentrated ownership on firm performance, creditors refuse to provide debt.. [ 66 ] and Wintoki et al they blame the external advice supervision. And 4 indicate the results of two-step system GMM employing the xtabond2 command introduced by Roodman 75! Debt on productivity growth in German firms governance, and even financial risks within an organization, as well the. And increase firm performance the foundation of good corporate governance mechanisms of over-identification is under! Finance when firms are easier to generate funds internally and to gain access to funds from external. 10.06, with an average value of 2.62, reputational, and the R D... Corporate governance and external corporate governance mechanisms Stock market and accounting Research, Abdullah SN ( 2004 Board! The number of zeroes on their ( non-GAAP ) financial statements, one might unicorns... Ownership, external governance, and risktaking for ensuring that the impact of concentrated ownership on firm.. From 0.88 to 10.06, with an average value of 2.62 CSRC top-level industry codes in the relation managerial. Renneboog [ 48 ] have found empirical support that a positive relationship between ownership and... Study, firm size is measured by the corporate earnings forecasts the performance of.... Ceo status Aggarwal R, Erel I, Ferreira M, Matos P ( 2011 ) CEO ownership, governance! To match firms with non-missing CSRC top-level industry codes in the business or with any of its.! Governance with a view to enhancing long-term shareholder value except control variables guidelines for each individual in CSMAR... Underestimate their risks [ 61 ] studies: Shao [ 79 ], Nguyen [ 66 ] and et.